Connecting with the ineffable in times of flattening
- Dr. Alessia Lupo Cecchet, La Montagna Addolorata [The Sorrowful Mountain]
- Alex Beth Schapiro, The Third That Remains: Rituals for Patients I Never Met
- Alexandre Sorokin, Noë / Red Cloud: An Apophatic Artistic Research Project
- Dr. Ally Zlatar, Worshipping The Porcelain Throne; Apophatic Autoethnography and Eating Disorders
- Asana Hues, The Significance of Insignificance
- Béatrice Machet, Paul Auster-apophatically-
- Bob Kalivac Carroll, Disruption and Apophasis: Ineffability and the Object Conundrum in Nonobjective Abstract Visual Art
- Caitlin Gilson and Carol Scott, A Conversation on Color: Poetry and Painting as Image, Glimpse, Moment
- Caitlin Mary Margarett Sørensdatter, The Fruits (Solastalgia in Skønvirke)
- Chandni Dhanesh Jeswani, What the City Refuses: Apophatic Cosmology and Structural Illegibility in Varanasi
- The Coven Collective: Chaelim Lim, Dima Mabsout, M. Maybee Salters, Nicole Sarmiento, and Tyler Rai, [Picking up shells amid a tsunami] 쓰나미가 밀려오는데, 조개나 줍고 있네.
- Daniel Martin and Dr. Marty Tomszak, Souls Moved by Intelligent Energies: Practice-Led Iconic Research and the Apophatic Theology of Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite
- Denise Gawley DMH MSN RN, Standing in the After
- Denise Gieseke, In the Movement of Dissolution
- Diana Rojas, Query v2; Subject to the Immaterial; Surveying the Messenger 1 & 2
- ELAWIATR, What Is Art – Apophatic Language in Fracture
- Eliza Swann, The eyeless mind
- Pr. émérite Emmanuel Gabellieri, L’expression et l’inexprimé
- Dr. Evgenii Matveev, Apophatic representation of Russia in Russian poetry
- Faizaan Ahab, Move
- Frank Smith, Les Films non exécutables
- Gabriel Figueroa, Chiesa
- Giulia Taurino, Ceci N’est Pas Une Archive: Negative Metadata and the Apophasis of Digital Records
- Dr. Gitanjaly Chhabra and Dr. Kathleen (Kaye) Hare, What Remains Unsaid: Apophatic Erasure in Academic Life and Luminous Edge of Absence
- Hamid Roslan, The Encounter
- iris yuting zeng, The Knot Before Language
- Ishita Dharap, Lossyness: Negotiations with what Routinely Escapes
- Jennifer Toriello, D. Litt., Held by What We Hold: Apophatic Weight and Embodied Practice in The Magic Hour
- Kaleb Ostraff, Touchpoints for the Ineffable
- Karin de Weille, Undone (spoken words)
- Keiran Dugan, Against Immediacy: Fictional Mediation and Apophatic Representation
- KPrevallet, Nothing Erased But Much Submerged
- Dr. Kythe Letitia Heller, S
- Dr. Laura McCullough, Compassionate Curiosity, Apophatic Storytelling, & the Healing Imagination: The Coordinates of Being
- Leslie N. Polk, peace, Colleague #2
- Dr. Lily Filson, The God in the Grotto: Renaissance Automata, Theurgy, and Apophatic Practice
- Marco Nieli, EKPHRASIS I, 121 ecphrastic carmina); EKPHRASIS II, 128 ecphrastic carmina in the 4 styles, with some haiku
- Martin Lenclos, Perception Is the First Creative Act: Toward an Apophatic Reading of Design for Nothing
- Martin Robb, Embracing the unknown: researching the hidden life and enigmatic art of Theodor Kern
- Mayson Taylor, 16 SHOWINGS Toward a Feminist Apophatic Art Practice
- Merel Thijs, On the colours of being: onto-teleological considerations on the artistic-creative process; With closed eyes open: portraits of the mind unwinding
- Mike Petrakis, Arteryficial Intelligence
- Nadine M. Kalin, What Is Withheld Does Not Lack: Waystop Pedagogy as Earth Scores in the Critical Zone
- Natalia Espinel and samantha shoppell, Un/wrapping Vulnerability
- Noelle Derksen, Apophasis and Trans Abstraction
- Radmila Djurica, Body in the Glitch
- Sarah Tarkany, Reticulated Silences
- Smita Sen, High Voltage: On The Heart, Defibrillation, and Competing Philosophies of Medicine
- Sophie Auger, third-image-archive.net
- Stephanie Smit (Giek), Soul Constellation Map — An Interactive Archive of Recurring Identities Across Time
- V.E. Haddad, the feeling when; Dream Commons
- Wayne Adams, Cloud of Unknowing
- William Franke, Desert and Sea: Apophatic Land/Sea Scapes
- Merel Visse
- William Franke
- Ryan Woodring
- Béatrice Machet
- Sarah Travis
- Enaiê Azambuja
- Sarah Tarkany
- Peter Kline
- Kythe Heller
- Cailtin Gilson
- Chelle Stearns
Kaleb Ostraff
Touchpoints for the Ineffable
It seems as though teachers and artists are increasingly being expected to define, explain, and concretize what art is in a prescriptive way that makes art more understandable systematic, predictable, and measurable. While some of these shifts are good and needed, it is also concerning because they leave little room for unknowing, curiosity, spontaneity, and ambiguity, which are the indeterminate spaces “art navigates best” (Camnizter, 2022, 04:05). While art can be indeterminate, ambiguous, and ineffable at times, it can also be a simple way of pointing things of significance out to each other and saying, “hey, look!” The artwork is a medium that connects the conceptual and abstract in a tangible form.
Through an essay exploring a variety of art pieces, I will explore how art can become a touchpoint for things in our lives that can be abstract and difficult to fully grasp or articulate in other ways. Artworks in this sense are openings to reflect on and get at the things that often lay outside our awareness helping to engage with what perplexes our soul… “the things we perceive but cannot name” (Goulish, 2022, n.p.). Getting at what it means to be human is not something that can ever be completely solved but is something that shifts and evolves as we change; thus, we have to come back to it repeatedly. While making art about our thoughts, experiences, or feelings often can fall short in capturing all that those things are, it can still make them have an aliveness because they exist in the world in a way where we can return to them and engage with them again.
Kaleb Ostraff is an artist, teacher, and scholar of education. Kaleb is currently an assistant professor of Art Education at Brigham Young University. He earned a PhD in Art Education at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. Before pursuing a PhD, he enjoyed teaching middle school art classes in public schools in Utah. His scholarship deals with the space where disciplines (art, education, museum studies, archives, cultural heritage) overlap and the potential these spaces provide for education and art making.